Talkin Sox with Dan

Where baseball fans gather for commonsensical, opinionated Red Sox banter.

Summarizing the Town Hall Meeting

Photo courtesy of

As previously blogged, I attended a town hall style meeting tonight at Worcester Technical High School hosted by NESN. GM Ben Cherington and Bobby Valentine answered a myriad of questions from the crowd. I took my sister who is an avid Red Sox fan. It was a fun event. It was free. And I didn’t embarrass myself too badly, but you can be the judge of that when the program airs tomorrow night at 10 PM on NESN. Let’s hit on a couple quick notes.

  • Worcester Tech’s campus is beautiful, and the auditorium was an ideal venue to play host to an event like tonight’s. I’m used to a plethora of aluminum chairs in a gym with a basketball hoop in the background. This was the opposite. Very professional. NESN has four microphones set up. Two were on each side of the stage–about seven feet away from Valentine and Cherington. The other two were situated towards the rear, just before the beginning of the second level of seating. The NESN employees did an excellent job ensuring that question-askers were in the right spot, at the right microphone at the right time. Tom Caron did a superb job hosting. He seamlessly transitioned between questions from the audience to general inquiries you would expect from a standard interview. I thought it was really well done.
  • I’m going to guess that 25-30 questions were asked. Half of the inquiries were made by Sox fans who were no older than 12. Pretty brave of the young fellas. When I was that age, I was just trying to avoid getting beat up, forget posing questions in front of hundreds of people to members of Red Sox brass.
  • It was a good question, but, contrary to popular belief, Valentine is not related to Greg “The Hammer” Valentine.
  • But he may have invented the wrap.
  • I wouldn’t be telling the truth if I said I didn’t end up shaking my head at a few ton of the questions that were posed to both Valentine and Cherington. One member of the audience has to be related to Marco Scutaro. Right now, do I believe that it was a shrewd move by Cherington to ship Scutaro to the Rockies? No, not yet. But this guy was really, really unhappy with the first-year GM.
  • I had told myself and a few buddies that if I did get the chance to ask a question, I would. The opportunity did present itself, and I took advantage of it. I immediately regretted my decision. Naturally, I was placed at one of the stage-side microphones (to the left of Cherington and Valentine). I was hoping to be escorted to one of the mikes towards the back of the auditorium in order to decrease the amount of sweat that seeped from my palms. When it was my turn, I asked the question that I believe is the most relevant question of the offseason: (quoted roughly) “The Marco Scutaro trade freed up close to $8MM in luxury tax dollars. $3MM has been allocated to Cody Ross, and $5-6MM is left. If you, as the GM of the Red Sox, are unable to obtain a quality starting pitcher before the season or at the trade deadline, will the Scutaro trade be viewed as a failure?”

–Cherington’s response is what you would expect–loaded with jargon about how the financial flexibility can’t just be attributed to Ross’ signing because there are players on the roster (Adrian Gonzalez, Jacoby Ellsbury, etc.) who will receive more money in 2012 than than they did the previous year. Essentially, the Red Sox look at payroll through a macro, not a micro, lens. In other words, the fiscal flexibility gained through the Scutaro trade could be used now to pluck a guy like Edwin Jackson or Roy Oswalt off of the market or utilized later for any number of roster moves that may or may not have a direct effect on the 2012 season (signing a draft pick, for example).

Remove the cameras and the audience–Cherington would agree that the success of the Scutaro trade is contingent upon the Red Sox ability to acquire a quality starting pitcher between now and the beginning of August. If that was not the case, the Red Sox would not still be involved in talks with Oswalt and Jackson.

About these ads

Single Post Navigation

8 thoughts on “Summarizing the Town Hall Meeting

  1. 2 things I took away from the event:

    1) Theo was one of the best speakers I’ve ever heard. Always calm and could deal with the media with ease. It was always striking to hear a press conference with both him and Lucchino. The difference was painfully obvious. Well, Ben is right there with Theo in that regard. INCREDIBLY smooth talker. I thought he did awesome last night. The way he also took the time to explain things that the average fan may not be familiar with (arbitration process being the main one I remember) was impressive.

    2) Bobby V is a character. Like, dude needs a reality show. He seems like a very likable guy. I couldn’t imagine Tito being as patient with some of the questions nor do I think Tito would have seemed to have enjoyed himself as much as Bobby. Doesn’t mean anything between the lines but, still nice to see.

    All in all I thought it was a really cool event. Glad I went. Curious to see how it looks tonight.

  2. Good point on the arbitration details. I thought that was a smart play by Cherington. Just adding some small points of interest to educate fans is always a good idea.

    Bobby Valentine is quite the character. Just different personalities between him and Tito. Bobby V should be on broadway.

  3. richard sierra on said:

    Take Edwin Jackson outta that equation, he’s headed to the nation’s capital according to yahoo sports

  4. With the sad news that Jackson is going to the Nationals.. (DAMMIT CHERINGTON) and Roy Oswalt not showing signs that he wants to pitch here.. I leave you with this hidden gem , to admire a man that has been the only good signing the sox have done this offseason..

  5. Just watched it. Pretty good show. But man, some of those questions were brutal. I mean, if those are the people that made it on air imagine the ones that hit the cutting room floor…

  6. Seriously. Who would ask a question anyways? Bunch of losers.

  7. Something I was wondering. How did you get your question in there? Craig and I were there the moments the doors opened and we had no idea how to ask a question till TC mentioned the ambassadors 5 minutes before the thing started. Did they go to your section or did you just see other people approaching them and followed suit? I had a couple questions in mind. Not sure if I would’ve had the guts to actually get up there or not but I never really even had the chance.

  8. No one went around for the majority of the event. One NESN employee asked the people in the row behind me. When he was walking by my row, I got his attention and told him I had a question.

    I was wicked nervous. In retrospect, I should have just sat there, not said anything, and high fived the mascots on the way out. ha-ha.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: